Monday, January 11, 2010

Negro Please!

This whole Harry Reid "scandal" is absolutely absurd, and is nothing more than a symptom of the vile political climate in this country. Was what he said less than tactful? Of course. Did he use an archaic term from a more racially fractured time in American history? Yes, and he probably used that term because he grew up in said period of time. And lastly, is what he said true? I think that if we were honest with ourselves we would have to answer in the affirmative. So he made an off the cuff remark using a racially insensitive word that just so happened to be true. He apologized to the person he made the statement about and that person forgave him. So what's the big deal?

The big deal is that our system is so screwed up that either side will do anything to score cheap political points. The idea that Reid should resign over what he said is ludicrous-- almost as ludicrous as these disingenuous schmucks on the right feigning outrage. And then to make it worse, the arguments Republicans are making about double standards, citing the Trent Lott remarks about Strom Thurmond, further displays their dimwittedness on race matters. Trent Lott lamented that a man who ran on a segregationist platform did not win the presidency. Let me see, saying "Gee Strom, I wish you would have become president and crushed the civil rights movement" is a little worse than Reid's inappropriate comment. But they don't seem to grasp that. The second a drop of blood hits the water, they just swarm. Because really, the truth is that they could give a damn about what Harry Reid said, they just want to take him down and gain power.

And that's a shame, because I really want to believe that there are good Republicans and Democrats who actually do want to work together for the good of the country. But as the Obama presidency has gone through it's first year, I struggle more so every day in believing that. And if I was honest, I would say that one side is worse. Above I said that "either side" will do anything to score cheap political points, and in the past that has probably been true, but the more I pay attention to politics (especially with the last election), the more I see the cheapest, most desperate and underhanded attacks coming from the right. For instance, the right has used everything from fear mongering about government takeovers to fear mongering about death panels to derail meaningful healthcare reform. And I can't help but believe they're now playing the race card to that end as well.

2 comments:

David Rudd said...

Chris,

I agree that this whole hullabaloo is a symptom of a fractured system.

but...

I certainly don't think you can blame the "right" for this one. At worst both sides are to blame.

I'm VERY confident that had Glen Beck or George Bush or Sarah Palin used the term "negro" they would be crucified for their insensitivity.

Do I think Reid should resign? No. But I think people lose their credibility when they try to defend him by arguing the "he was factually right" line.

The left would NEVER let the right dismiss someone's insensitivity by using that line, and rightly so.

Everybody's got to play by the same rules.

chris o said...

i agree that a republican who made the same statement be crucified. and i would be saying that democrats who were making a big deal over it are wrong to do so.

and i don't disagree that both sides are to blame for this cheap tit for tat garbage. YET, i can't help but notice that i see the worst, and most ridiculous, of it coming from the right.

lastly, yes the left wouldn't let anyone get away with saying "well it IS true", but it is. and i would say that the rules are part of the problem, and we need new ones.